Mastering Civil Procedure: Doctrine, Practice & Context


Mastering Civil Procedure: Doctrine, Practice & Context

The framework governing how courts resolve disputes between private parties encompasses a body of rules, established principles, and interpretive precedents. This framework shapes the course of litigation, from initial pleadings through discovery, trial, and appeal. Its application is influenced not only by the written law but also by the customs and conventions observed by legal professionals and the prevailing societal conditions in which disputes arise.

A thorough understanding of this legal architecture is crucial for effective advocacy and fair adjudication. It ensures consistency, predictability, and transparency in the judicial process. Historically, the development of these procedural mechanisms reflects efforts to balance efficiency with justice, adapting to changing societal needs and technological advancements to provide equitable access to the courts.

Read more

Step Transaction Doctrine: Smaldino Court Test Guide


Step Transaction Doctrine: Smaldino Court Test Guide

The legal principle that is subject to scrutiny involves a series of formally separate steps that are, in substance, integrated components of a single transaction. Courts examine such arrangements to determine the tax consequences based on the overall result, rather than the individual steps. For example, if an individual sells property to a related party, then that related party quickly sells the property to an outside entity, the initial sale may be disregarded if the court finds the transactions were interdependent and designed to minimize tax liability. This ensures taxation reflects the actual economic outcome.

This doctrine prevents taxpayers from achieving tax results that are inconsistent with the economic reality of their dealings. Historically, it has served as a significant tool for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to combat tax avoidance schemes. Its application promotes fairness and equity within the tax system by ensuring that similar economic activities are taxed similarly, regardless of the formal structure adopted by the taxpayer.

Read more

close
close